Ticket #1973 (closed poll)

Opened 2 years ago

Last modified 2 years ago

Poll: Improve air handling

Reported by: Saktoth Owned by:
Priority: major Milestone:
Component: CA Version:
Keywords: Cc:

Description (last modified by Saktoth) (diff)

Change History

Changed 2 years ago by Saktoth

  • description modified (diff)

Using the air handling tags, i can dramatically increase the handling of bombers etc. This may lead to some weirdness in the movement AI but hopefully it can be avoided.

Do we want to do this? It may make air more interesting and engaging to micro.

Try the Flea and Laser Area bomber (armpnix2 and 3) for examples of how tight we can make our air handle.

Changed 2 years ago by Google Frog

I'm worried that this won't actually add anything to air. We may end up nerfing bombers due to new micro with the only outcome being more pointless micro. Worth a try though.

Changed 2 years ago by licho

Its not more controllable, it just makes sharper turns. But the annoying moments where it refuses to respond happens still. I dont like it much because bomber turning in place looks unnatural.

Changed 2 years ago by SirMaverick

ACK @ Google

But the annoying moments where it refuses to respond happens still.

Because that is a different issue.

unnatural

Don't we all already know that realism isn't an argument?

Changed 2 years ago by licho

Natural feel != realism.

Its matching the game general expectations of players.

They expect tank to have more HP than small infrantry kbots.

They expect ships to move in water and move slower than aircrafts.

And they dont expects aircrafts to turn on pinhead.

"Natural" feel, meaning "what players expect" is much more important than realism.

Changed 2 years ago by Google Frog

Here are the effects as I see them:

  • Bombers will require much more micro. They will have to be balanced with the extra control in mind.
  • The point of no return for a bomber strike will be much closer to enemy AA.
  • It will be easier to stop bombers from doing stupid things.

The only point I really like is the last one.

Changed 2 years ago by KingRaptor

  • status changed from new to closed

Winner: Yes (75%)

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.